Welcome
Downloads Home
Best Files
Review Guidelines
Main site
Forums
Code of Conduct
Search

Advanced Search
1v1 ROTWK Replays
Home
New Releases
New Reviews
New Comments
Top-Rated

Submit File
Browse Categories

Downloads Home » 1v1 ROTWK Replays » mfk|Evilnemesis[Elves] vs Lalopasando[Dwarves]

Download File Post Review Post Comment

mfk|Evilnemesis[Elves] vs Lalopasando[Dwarves]

Author File Description
Evilnemesis
File Details
Player 1's Name: mfk|Evilnemesis
Player 1's Faction: Elves
Player 2's Name: Lalopasando
Player 2's Faction: Dwarves
Victor: mfk|Evilnemesis
Comments/Feedback
AuthorComments & Reviews   ( All | Comments Only | Reviews Only )
J0nNy
Rating
2.0
mfk|Evilnemesis (Elves) vs Lalopasando (Dwarves)



Lalopasando

Buildorder: Mine+Hall of warriors--->Mine at eco-building
Strategy: guardians+phalanx--->dain--->men of dale

+ good buildorder
+ went fast too the eco-building
+ expanded good at the beginning
+ tryed to attack

= im not sure, but i think its not good to use men of dale on the battlewagon
= i would use the hobbits with their stones (more damage)

- the tower in the middle was useless for its price
- you didnt protect your economy
- no stances
- you got a bad power at the beginning and used it without a sense
- no clumping
- dain was always jsut living a few minutes
- sent your bw's into pikes
- you could have killed the ents, which destroyed your fortress (nearly)
- no more expanding after a few minutes

You did a in my opinion very good start, but when you built the tower i could see that you are not as good as i thought...and it was true, you used a nearly useless power (for the beginning), you didnt expand after the start, you lost all your expensive units always very fast...i cant give you more than 1,5 points.

Rating: 1,5


mfk|Evilnemesis

Buildorder: Tree+Stables--->Tree
Strategy: cav--->infantry-spam--->glrofindel--->ents

+ you had the most time the eco-building
+ your usage of glorfindel was not bad
+ you expanded when you pushed him back
+ destroyed eco

= you used stances...but not enough
= the ent power wasnt that good used, the dwarv could have killed them easily

- your buildorder had a too weak economy and too late the horses...better go for 2 trees and then stables..im sure that works better
- you dont need the warchant for creeping
- you dont need 3 barracks...2 are enough, better produce while fighting and then go for upgrades or mirkwoods instead of spamming expensive units
- you lost your rank 2 horses and could have saved them
- no clumping
- you could have run to the nearly destroyed castle with glorfindel and kill it fast...he just needs 2 hits for a that much damaged castle

your start wasnt good in my opinion, but you got the economy-building and become the better palyer of this game...but you had too much production buildings and didnt use them right (with 2 barracks you could have produced the same number of units)...better go for mirkwoods or/and upgrades...if you want to spam better play an evil race. im sorry but u made too much mistakes for a better ranking...this game you get just 2 points...but ill have a look at following ones ;)

Rating: 2


Overall: both players made lots of mistakes, but it was a game were you dont know for a long time who wins, so the entertaining in this point isnt bad, but it could have more action and, what i said before less mistakes on both sides...thats why i give just 2 points.

Rating: 2

Post Review Post Comment

HGDL v0.7.1

Login
Forum Username:


Password:




Create a new account
Forgot password?
Rating
2.0
Statistics
Downloads:216
Favorites: [Who?]0
Size:17.95 KB
Added:09/16/07
New Files