Welcome
Downloads Home
Best Files
Review Guidelines
Main site
Forums
Code of Conduct
Search

Advanced Search
1v1 ROTWK Replays
Home
New Releases
New Reviews
New Comments
Top-Rated

Submit File
Browse Categories

Downloads Home » 1v1 ROTWK Replays » Dwarves vs men

Download File Post Review Post Comment

Dwarves vs men

Author File Description
Sir Snoopy
File Details
Player 1's Name: Sir Snoopy
Player 1's Faction: Dwarves
Player 2's Name: Someone
Player 2's Faction: Men of the West
Victor: The under dog
Please tell me what I did wrong
AuthorReviews   ( All | Comments Only | Reviews Only )
Smeagolfan24
Official Reviewer
Rating
3.0
[center][c=9966ff]1 v 1 on Withered Heath
SirSnoopy001 (Dwarves) vs. Yulio (MOTW)[/center][/c]

[b][i]SirSnoopy001 (Dwarves)[/b][/i]

Build Order: [i] Mine >>> Archery Range >>> Mine >>> Axe Throwers[/i]

[c=green]Pros[/c]

[+] It seemed like your economy was very strong to begin with. You never ran out of money, giving you a continual stream of units to harass him. :D
[+] Killed his builder! Nice job!
[+] Good job being aware that he wasn’t building pikemen and countering it by your battlewagon.
[+]

[c=blue]Averages[/c]

[=] You used stances, but then forgot to later on.
[=] Relocation could have been an option, but that’s difficult.
[=] So-so location of the Range. Behind the fortress is the way to go, IMO.
[=] Good use of Rallying Call.

[c=red]Cons[/c]

[-] When performing a rush, it’s normally better to ignore the enemy units and go straight for his buildings, economy first. They’ll continue to attack you, but you have new throwers coming in all the time, so it wouldn’t have been a problem.
[-] Your offence fell down, due to Rangers and two Heroes. That’s hard to counter, but if that happens again, try and get him off balance by destroying his archery range or barracks. If you can do that you can get back, but that’s a tough situation. *sad*
[-] Why did you lose? You stopped attacking the buildings and started attacking his powerful units.

[b]Overall score: 3.5[/b]

An excellent rush that just needs a little more offense. You had the upper hand at first, then for some reason fell apart. You’re almost there, and I can see you improving. Thing to work on: Moving into the late game strategies (upgrades, heroes, siege).

[b][i]Yulio (MOTW)[/b][/i]

Build Order: [i] Farm >>> Farm >>> Barracks >>> Soldiers[/i]

[c=green]Pros[/c]

[+] Good quick Faramir that you leveled up [i]very[/i] quickly.
[+] At the end you had an overwhelming amount of units with two powerful heroes leveled up. I’m still not sure how you got them, though.
[+] A pretty good location for your Archery Range, which was made even better by the Fortress expansion to guard it.

[c=blue]Averages[/c]

[=] Spearmen were unnecessary.
[=] You really had no rush or forward anything; you won by superior troops in the end.

[c=red]Cons[/c]

[-] No stances. :angry:
[-] I’ve an idea, let’s stop and destroy this lair on our way to destroy our enemy! Wrong!
[-] Really bad location of your barracks.

[b]Overall score: 3[/b]

Meh, you played a good win, but it was really boring to watch you play. You spammed Soldiers until you changed to spam Rangers. Some cavalry would have defeated his only unit, Axe Throwers even more quickly.

Overall Game Score:[b]3[/b]

An interesting (relatively quick, too) game with a nice Axe Thrower rush, but nothing no one has seen before. if you have the time. *wink*

Post Review Post Comment

HGDL v0.7.1

Login
Forum Username:


Password:




Create a new account
Forgot password?
Rating
3.0
Statistics
Downloads:217
Favorites: [Who?]0
Size:12.81 KB
Added:07/06/07
New Files