Welcome
Downloads Home
Best Files
Review Guidelines
Main site
Forums
Code of Conduct
Search

Advanced Search
1v1 Replays
Home
New Releases
New Reviews
New Comments
Top-Rated

Submit File
Browse Categories
New Files

Downloads Home » 1v1 Replays » dwarves versus elves rise of the witch king

Download File Post Review Post Comment

dwarves versus elves rise of the witch king

Author File Description
insanesameri
File Details
Player 1's Name: insanesameri (me)
Player 1's Faction: Dwarves
Player 2's Faction: Elves
this is a kool replay in which is killed the elves after the took down my fort. Its one you will want to downlaod if you play as dwarves.
AuthorComments & Reviews   ( All | Comments Only | Reviews Only )
Smeagolfan24
Official Reviewer
Rating
3.0
1 v. 1 on Celduin River
insanesameri (Dwarves) vs. Asav (Elves)

insanesameri (Dwarves)

Build Order: Mine >>> Mine >>> Archery Range >>> Mine

Pros

[+] Nice steady stream of throwers at start.
[+] Got as close to a troll lair as possible.
[+] Good use of nearby tower
[+] Once you got Gloin, the tide was turned. Slightly.
[+] Nice job using the late-game units such as the Zealots and the catapults. They were what beat the enemy waves.
[+] Kept the northern signal fire the whole game

Averages

[=] Stances! Defensive stance when not attacking!
[=] Wagon upgrades?
[=] Bought Heal when really not needed. Rallying Call would have helped way more, earlier.
[=] Didn’t really keep your outposts, but you maintained an inn a while that gave you all of your Dale archers.
[+] So-so use of Summon Dale Archers power.

Cons

[-] Bad placement of first mines and buildings. If attempting an axe-thrower rush, one should be more forward and the other protected, IMO.
[-]Early on, you almost lost one of your builders to a cave troll!
[-] Powers? You didn’t even buy any until mid-game!
[-] You let your units sit around and get killed. Better micro.
[-] Lost your fortress after waiting til the last minute to counter his Ents.

Player Rating: 3 You did some good things, but you won because your opponent didn’t get Ents. Work on your micro to seal the game quicker and easier.

Asav (Elves)

Build Order: Tree >>> Arwen >>> [Outposts] >>> Stables >>> Tree

Pros

[+] Early Arwen to capture buildings.
[+] Kept steady waves coming at your opponent, mainly of cavalry that decimated him.
[+] Nice choices with powers.
[+] Very fine defense with towers and statues.

Averages

[=] Swiftly got Mirkwoods w/ Silverthorn, but they died rather quickly.
[=] Late game heroes came rather…late, don’t you think?
[=] Legolas > Elrond in this game, at least.

Cons

[-] Normally focused on taking out units, rather than buildings.
[-] Stances, stances, stances! Your Summoned Ents could have destroyed his fortress much more promptly had they been in Aggressive Stance.
[-] Late game siege? Ents would have turned the game in your favor.

Player Rating: 3.5 I really think you played better throughout the entire match; you just got too confident and fell apart at the end. Try to improve late game strats.


Overall Score of Game: 3

Not a bad game, overall. It's a games with a lot of "waves" that was enjoyable to watch. Worth your time, if you've got the time.

Post Review Post Comment

HGDL v0.8.0

Login
Forum Username:


Password:




Create a new account
Forgot password?
Rating
3.0
Statistics
Downloads:253
Favorites: [Who?]0
Size:79.41 KB
Added:02/04/07