Welcome
Downloads Home
Best Files
Review Guidelines
Main site
Forums
Code of Conduct
Search

Advanced Search
1v1 Replays
Home
New Releases
New Reviews
New Comments
Top-Rated

Submit File
Browse Categories
New Files

Downloads Home » 1v1 Replays » 1v1 Hit and run tactics

Download File Post Review Post Comment

1v1 Hit and run tactics

Author File Description
Legolaim
File Details
Total Game Time: 30 minutes
Player 1's Name: GoS[Legolaim]
Player 1's Faction: Men of the West
Player 2's Name: GoS[GeneralVon]
Player 2's Faction: Mordor
This is an example of a basic hit and run tactic which proves mordor still has a chance this patch.
AuthorComments & Reviews   ( All | Comments Only | Reviews Only )
SuicidalScotsman
Official Reviewer
Rating
3.5
GoS[Legolaim] VS GoS[GeneralVon]

Played on Fords of Isen II

Player Review: Legolaim (Men of the West)

Starting Strat: Farm, Barracks, Farm, Barracks, (Spam Soldiers)

Positives

[+]Double Rax Spam
[+]Got Boromir early enough
[+]Hidden stables
[+]Clumped and got both orc pits down
[+]Got Elven wood as first power
[+]Ivory tower

Averages

[=]you used Boromirs horn OK
[=]you rebuilt your farms, but it took a while
[=]you needed archers, and only built one battalion of expensive weak ones

Negatives

[-]You still focus on 1.04 tactics of ignoring troops and going for buildings. Big mistake
[-]You never bought banners for your barracks OR your fortress
[-]No heal spell. Could have saved Boromir, plus, Tom bombadil is a pretty slow guy, and can't catch up to archers.
[-]Spent almost all time on aggressive, should have changed to defensive when attacked by Mounted Nazgul
[-]Your use of cavalry seemed almost desperate in my eyes, not much for effectiveness in a blind charge onto tainted land soldiers

Player Summary: Well, you're still trying to get the hang of men of the west right now. You still use the 1.04 Strategy of focusing purely on spamming, and not enough effort on upgrades. You got the Ivory tower yes, but the Banners from both the fortress and the Barracks would both have been crucial to help you survive. Keep getting beeter, Good try.

Rating: 2.5/5




Player Review: GeneralVon (Mordor)

Starting Strat: SH, SH, Pit, Pit, Archers X2, (Spam orcs)

Positives

[+]Got Early Nazgul
[+]Spamming was quite good, even for nerfed orcs
[+]Excellent corsair use
[+]Got upgrades, giving you a huge advantage
[+]Fellbeasts
[+]Great harassment

Averages

[=]you took a while sometimes to attack, IMO you could have won sooner
[=]The fellbeasts weren't necessary, you were fine with the mounted Nazgul
[=]Orcs in aggressive = pointless

Negatives

[-]Starting with archers has never been a solid strategy, IMO spamming tons of orcs as a meat shield would be better
[-]Eh...? Not much else to say

Player Summary: Well done! You won. I must say, Orcs still have a purpose in this game, and that was some interesting Nazgul and Corsair use. You don't need advice from me methinks, so just keep on playing the way you are!

Rating: 4/5

Final Comments: A decent match with some highlights. Watch it for some clan mates action, and for anyone looking for how to play mordor with orcs

Match Rating: 3.5/5

[Edited on 10/10/06 @ 07:48 PM]

GeneralVon death. why is archers a bad idea as a first unit?! ur crazy. i made 2 SH and if i made orcs they wouldn't be able to do much to defend the SH. 2 archers, 1 to defend each SH. :)
GeneralVon also, agresive orcs = stronger orcs. they were on tainted land.

Post Review Post Comment

HGDL v0.8.0

Login
Forum Username:


Password:




Create a new account
Forgot password?
Rating
3.5
Statistics
Downloads:558
Favorites: [Who?]0
Size:90.29 KB
Added:10/06/06