Downloads Home
Best Files
Review Guidelines
Main site
Code of Conduct

Advanced Search
1v1 Replays
New Releases
New Reviews
New Comments

Submit File
Browse Categories
New Files

Downloads Home » 1v1 Replays » Kester vs Brown6614

Download File Post Review Post Comment

Kester vs Brown6614

Author File Description
File Details
Total Game Time: ~20-25 minutes
Player 1's Name: Kester
Player 1's Faction: Men of the West
Player 2's Name: Brown6614
Player 2's Faction: Goblins
A quickmatch between two pretty equally ranked players. Me (Kestria) as MotW and Brown6614 as Goblins.
AuthorReviews   ( All | Comments Only | Reviews Only )
Victor von Doom
Official Reviewer
Kestria (Men of the West) verus Brown6614 (Goblins)
Played on Rohan

Player Review: Kestria

[+]You defended your base well with Rangers
[+]You had a nice Rohirrim harass
[+]You hit his forward tunnel early

[=]You got the Outposts (Only reason this isn't a + is because you didn't get them right away)

[-]Why didn't you clump (Yes I wrote these notes before Bendak's guide )
[-]You lost a buider kind of early
[-]After you lost your first few soldiers, you stopped your offense
[-]You didn't put Rangers in towers?
[-]You didn't get Boromir
[-]You lost Thoeden pretty fast

Overall: 1.5/5
For your first time playing as MotW, it was OK, but there were alot of things you could fix. Like you should take advantage of the OPness of Rangers in towers, they get a range bonus when on hills, and they pwn all of Gobos stuff. Also, you didn't get Outposts until later in the game. You have a bit you can improve upon. (No offense)

Player Review: Brown6614

[+]Good useage of Poison Blade

[=]Forward Tunnel was a good idea but you coudl've hid it better, or not made one, espically on a small map considering the speed of Goblins.
[=]You had a Fissure but you didn't use it until alot later in the game!

[-]You let your Goblins idle! With Goblins you must always harass!
[-]You wasted Warchant a few times
[-]You took about one Outpost the entire game
[-]You didn't use the Forward Tunnel
[-]Again, no climping from you either?
[-]You sent 2 Archers and 1 Warrior to fight? Why?
[-]Only ONE Cave
[-]You got more spiderlings then Spider Riders
[-]No spiderling expansions
[-]You turtled with a spam faction

Overall: 1.5/5
You could've played this game alot better. I mean, you only got one Cave? In most games when I play with Goblins, I use at least 3 or 4 and I start off with two. Although you did turtle well considering your faction, you just don't turtle with a spam faction. You have to spam! I was waiting for the FU Half Troll rush, but then I saw an army of FU goblins. You could use some improvement, IMO.

Game Overall: 2/5
This game is pretty dull in my opinion. No offense to the players, but you both could use some help. Also, I was shocked by the lack of both of your not-getting-Outposts-early strats. Normall I go for Outposts with my first battalion. This is game is worth a watch if you have free time, but you definetally could watch some better replays or play some games instead.

Post Review Post Comment

HGDL v0.8.0

Forum Username:


Create a new account
Forgot password?
Favorites: [Who?]0
Size:43.06 KB