You must be logged in to post messages.
Please login or register

Replays
Moderated by Sir Hugh, Atzy, Blatant

Hop to:    
Welcome! You are not logged in. Please Login or Register.9 replies
Battle for Middle Earth II Heaven » Forums » Replays » Replay review pls
Bottom
Topic Subject:Replay review pls
Paronsplit
Dúnadan
posted 09-08-06 12:20 PM EDT (US)         
May I have this replay reviewed. A pretty good game. Maybe even a replay of the week :P Not the best teamwork I have to admit, but I think me(BryrMejInte) and Lunkan did a good game.
AuthorReplies:
Revan
GreenFan PAO 13
(id: LOrd_REvan)
posted 09-08-06 12:22 PM EDT (US)     1 / 9       
I'll try to review it as soon as possible !

VVD get your BFME2 fixed now !



-- Revan--


u called down the thunder...
...now reap the whirlwind !
Paronsplit
Dúnadan
posted 09-08-06 12:23 PM EDT (US)     2 / 9       
Thank you!
pigelin
Dúnadan
posted 09-11-06 02:17 PM EDT (US)     3 / 9       
I know that you perhaps don't have much time on your hand, but have you forgotten this replay? I would like to have a review on this one aswell...Because I am in it!!

Pigelin and Paronsplit - da mean killing machine
Or, maybe not...

Member Since: 03-04-2006

Revan
GreenFan PAO 13
(id: LOrd_REvan)
posted 09-11-06 02:22 PM EDT (US)     4 / 9       
Of course I do not have forgotten this replay.Don't worry.You'll have your review soon.


-- Revan--


u called down the thunder...
...now reap the whirlwind !
Revan
GreenFan PAO 13
(id: LOrd_REvan)
posted 09-12-06 05:03 PM EDT (US)     5 / 9       
Lunkan(Isengard) - BryrMejlnte (Elves)
vs
G3hlrvn5chwand(Mordor) - KiFFCuT (Dwarves)

Played on Minhiriath as a 2v2 Game.

TEAM 1

Player Lunkan:

BO: Furnace (x2),Warg Pit,Warg Riders (x2),Uruk Pit,Crossbowmen
Positives

[+]You destroyed 2 of his mines and his Hall of warriors with your Wargs. Impressive and succesful Warg Rush !
[+]Get Lurtz pretty quickly.
[+]Nice use of the standard Isengard strategy (Warg Rush + Bows + Lurtz)
[+]Get upgrades ! Forged blades helped you destroyed the Dwarven base and thus finishing the game.

[=]No the best possible building location. Especially your Warg Pit was badly placed.
[=]Average use of the Crebain Birds power.

negatives

[-]Bad hero micro.If I remeber well you let Lurtz dying 2 times !
[-]Not defense at all. Mordor player destroyed your Warg Pit and heavily damaged your Uruk Pit with a single Orc bat !
[-]Not cooperation .No team work. (as you said)


Player :BryrMejlnte

BO: Malorn Tree,Barracks,Malorn Tree,Lorien Archers (x1)
Positives

[+]You built your buildings in very good locations.
[+]Very good defense against the Guardian Rush.
[+]You get upgrades first. Especially your Silverthorn arrows research was done pretty fast !
[+]Map control !

negatives

[-]No hero ?
[-]No harassment ?
[-]You should be more aggressive. You shouldn't have left the enemy mordor player to help his mate !

TEAM Summary :

Once again , you improved your personal play but your team work wasn't the best (again ;p).Sorry , it's boring to continually hear : "Team work-team work-team work..." but in 2vs2 matches (balanced matches) , team work is the most important factor. This time your enemies were better (especially the Mordor player) but not like you. Result : Big improvement in solo play no improvement at team work.

Rating : 3/5

TEAM 2

Player : G3hlrvn5chwand

BO:Slaughter house , Orcpits (x2),Ork Warriors

Positives

[+](Nice name ! - definitely is helping RRs to do their job ! )
[+]You helped your mate pretty good !
[+]Captured the inn first !
[+]You get hero first !
[+]You built your buildings in very good locations.

[=]You get Catas but it was too late.

Negatives

[-]Stances ? Your micro wasn't very good. (unit & hero micro)
[-]Weak mate.
[-]You should have turtled your fortress much more. (catas around+ 3 Gate Watchers + Arrow Barracks)


Player : KiFFCuT

BO:Hall of Warriors , mine , Guardian Warriors (x2),forward mine.

Positives

[+]Good position of your forward mine.
[+]Your base was almost destroyed but you didn't give up !

Negatives

[-]Bad Guardian Rush. You did need one more Guardian battalion and defensive stance.
[-]Left your base completely unprotected many times.
[-]Stances ? No good micro at all.
[-]Bad position of your barracks


TEAM Summary :

The Mordor player of your team played good but the other played pretty bad. KiFCuT you must improve your solo game.The successful Guardian Rush is : 3 Guardian bats (defensive stance) + Rallying Call.The only thing you had better than your opponents was your team-work.

Rating : 1.5/5


Match Rating : 2.5/5

Good 2vs2 game.Fun to watch it.



-- Revan--


u called down the thunder...
...now reap the whirlwind !
RedN0mad
Dúnadan
posted 09-13-06 04:29 AM EDT (US)     6 / 9       

Quote:

The successful Guardian Rush is : 3 Guardian bats (defensive stance) + Rallying Call.The only thing you had better than your opponents was your team-work.

That's 2 Guardian bats... 3 will probably be too late.

Paronsplit
Dúnadan
posted 09-13-06 10:54 AM EDT (US)     7 / 9       
Thx for the review.
Lunkan(Pigelin here at heavengames) and me are working on our teamwork. I really don't know why it never seems to work as it should. But I guess we have to keep on playing, and maybe against some better opponents to learn.

Thx again for the review. We might send in some more replays (with another topic than "replay review pls" :P) and hopefully we'll have a better teamwork.

Revan
GreenFan PAO 13
(id: LOrd_REvan)
posted 09-13-06 01:33 PM EDT (US)     8 / 9       
I'll be glad to review more replays of yours.Stronger opponents would be great.And don't forget : it's better loosing by a strong opponent than winning a weak one.

Quote:

That's 2 Guardian bats... 3 will probably be too late.

Not really.Check this link.I agree with Zimland.It takes you a bit longer but +1 Guardian bat is the finishing blow.



-- Revan--


u called down the thunder...
...now reap the whirlwind !
Revan
GreenFan PAO 13
(id: LOrd_REvan)
posted 09-17-06 08:10 AM EDT (US)     9 / 9       
Congrats! This replay is the replay of the week !


-- Revan--


u called down the thunder...
...now reap the whirlwind !
You must be logged in to post messages.
Please login or register

Hop to:    

Battle for Middle Earth II Heaven | HeavenGames